Weekly Chasidic Story #1111 (s5779-29/
18 Adar B, 5779)
The Prince, the Queen, and the Rabbi
The Rabbi was invited to a very special dinner in Canada with Queen Elizabeth
II of England and her husband, Prince Phillip. He informed the organizers that
he would be unable to attend because of his special dietary needs.
Connection: This week's Torah reading of Shemini contains much information
about Keeping Kosher
Story in PDF
format for more convenient printing.
The Prince, the Queen, and the Rabbi
One time, Rabbi Marvin Hier was invited to a very special
dinner in Victoria Canada with Queen Elizabeth II of England [and other Commonwealth
nations such as Canada] and her husband, Prince Phillip. He informed the organizers
that although he was quite touched and flattered by the invitation, he would
be unable to attend because of his special dietary needs.
But the Canadian government held Rabbi Hier [who led the Shaarei Tzedek Congregation
in Vancouver, B.C., Canada, from 1964-1977,] in great esteem. They were willing
to accommodate his every wish. And so, they assured him that he would have his
own set of dishes and cutlery and of course, special kosher food.
Greeted by Queen Elizabeth herself, Rabbi Hier and his wife were quite honored
to attend a dinner of such dignitaries. But, to their chagrin, after the first
course, in an effort to allow all the guests to acquaint themselves with one
another, all the guests were asked to move to another seat.
A nice idea, but not for the Rabbi and his wife. For them it created quite
a problem. What would he now do about his kosher food and utensils? Although
it would look strange, he and his wife decided that they were going to have
to bring along their dishes and cutlery to whichever seat they moved to. Indeed,
there were those who stared and thought it to be quite strange and even rude.
In fact, one unaffiliated Jew was quite disturbed by the "Hillul Hashem"
(disgracing of G-d's name). How could it be that the Rabbi would act in such
a difficult manner when the royal family had gone to such great lengths to accommodate
him, he challenged.
Regardless of what it looked like, the Rabbi was not about to compromise on
his standards. And so, he brought his plate with him wherever he went. The Queen
and her husband walked about the room greeting the various dignitaries. And
when Prince Phillip noticed the Rabbi standing with his plate in his hands,
he asked about the peculiar behavior.
Rabbi Hier explained why he had to carry around his dishes and utensils, and
his explanation impressed the prince. Expressing curiosity as to the details
of this religious practice, the prince engaged the rabbi in a relatively lengthy
discussion about the laws of keeping kosher. Eager to share this new revelation,
Prince Phillip even included Queen Elizabeth in the conversation.
Shortly thereafter, seeing how well received the Rabbi was, this irreligious
fellow decided that he, too, would capitalize on his Jewishness. He approached
Prince Phillip and introduced himself as another Jew. But the prince looked
at him disapprovingly and asked him one piercing question: "If you are
a Jew, then where are your dishes?"
Needless to say, the embarrassed fellow sheepishly walked away.
Source: Adapted by Yerachmiel Tilles from an article by Rabbi
Reuven Semah, which was first published in the Parshat Ki Sisa 5778 (2018) email
of the Jersey Shore Torah Bulletin, then reprinted in an email of Shabbat Shalom
from Cyberspace. Submitted by Daniel Keren ("Shabbos Stories for the Parsha").
Biographical note: Rabbi Moshe "Marvin" Hier [born
1939 in New York City] is the dean and founder of the Simon Wiesenthal Center,
its Museum of Tolerance and of Moriah, the Center's film division.
Connection: This week's Torah reading of Shemini contains much
information about Keeping Kosher.
Editor's note: for a very interesting (although much lengthier)
story that concludes with the same theme, see #1005 in this series, "Queen
Esther of Jerusalem"
Appendix (from a long, mostly negative article about Rabbi Hier that appeared
in the LA Times on July 15, 1990) - another episode from that dinner:
Hier"s message is that Jews are never safe, that anti-Semitism is pandemic,
occurring everywhere and in various degrees of virulence, and no matter the
occasion, Jews must always stand up for themselves.
"I have experienced anti-Semitism in public life in a very profound way,"
says Hier, harking back to his dinner with the Queen. Sitting at his table--Hier
had ordered a kosher meal--was a kilt-clad Canadian admiral holding forth on
the ethnicity he declared was ruining Canada. The admiral turned to Hier and
said: "Take you, rabbi. Here we all are having dinner. And you have to
Hier turned to the admiral in distaste: "With all due respect, sir,"
Hier said, "if you are not embarrassed to sit amongst us wearing a skirt,
I don't think I have to be embarrassed about what I choose to eat."
Tilles is co-founder and associate director of Ascent-of-Safed, and chief editor
of this website (and of KabbalaOnline.org). He has hundreds of published stories
to his credit, and many have been translated into other languages. He tells
them live at Ascent nearly every Saturday night.
To receive the Story by e-mail every Wednesday--sign
"Festivals of the
("Under the Full Moon" vol 2 - holiday stories)
is now available
for purchase from ASCENT
* ~ * ~ * ~ * ~ *
Book 1 of Yerachmiel Tilles's 3-volume set,
"Saturday Night, Full Moon",
is also available for purchase on
back to Top back
to this year's Story Index Stories
home page Stories Archives